Currency Hedging, Forex Consulting Services.

Forex Hedging Cost Comparison Tool

Compare Carry Spot Forex Hedges to Bank Forward Contracts

This tool compares the cost difference (or rate difference) between a carry spot forex hedge and a forex forward contract, outlining the savings of using one method over the other.

Enter the required information (reporting and foreign currencies, the amount—use a minus sign for liabilities, and number of days until the forward date). Optionally, enter the forward rate quoted to you by your bank to view a cost comparison breakdown that shows if they’re giving you a fair deal or not.

Tell Us...
Your Reporting Currency
The Foreign Currency
The Balance Sheet Foreign Asset (Liability)
The Estimated Hedge Life in Days?
Forward Date
(Optional)The Forward Rate Quoted to You
  
  

Hedge Cost Comparison Summary
  FX Rate* () Your Currency Is Worth () Savings (Cost) () Interest Rate Safety Margin (Annual %)
Today's Spot Rate        
Alternative Hedging Rates (Settling in Days)
Carry Spot Trade        
Estimated Forward Contract        
Quoted Forward Contract        

Actual carry spot trade costs may vary depending on changes in future interest rates charged/earned on the currency pair(s) traded.

Actual forward rates depend on a number of factors, including the provider's interest risk premium and the provider’s profit when issuing the forward contract.

This table shows a comparison summary of carry spot vs. forward contract rates for the amounts you entered above. See the Hedge Cost Comparison Breakdown table below for details on how these amounts are calculated.

The Interest Rate Safety Margin field shows the amount interest rates would need to change unfavorably, immediately and for the entire timeframe, to make the carry spot hedge less attractive than the forward contract estimate.


Carry Spot Trades Required to Complete Hedge*
Currency Pair Position Direction Units Buy Rate Sell Rate

This table shows the currency pair trade(s) required to complete the hedge on the OANDA FXTrade platform. (If it's a synthetic pair, two or more trades are required.) Depending on the asset/liability you are hedging, you either buy (go long) or sell (go short) the first currency in the pair.

The buy and sell rates shown are the OANDA FXTrade rates at the time of calculation, and were used to calculate both the carry spot and forward contract estimates. Forex rates change constantly, so you should update the rates often. (To see the latest rates, click the Refresh Rates at the top of this page.)

Hedge Cost Comparison Breakdown 
  Estimated Carry Spot Trade Rate Estimated Forward Contract Rate Your Quoted Forward Contract Rate
Hedge Amount () - Current Spot Amount      
Estimated Spread Cost*      
Estimated Interest Differential (Interest Carry Costs)**      
Estimated Cost to Cover Interest Risk 0.00    
Estimated Forward Transaction Profit 0.00 250  
Total Estimated Hedging Cost      
Total Estimated Future Amount      
Estimated Forex Rate      
Savings (Cost) Compared to Carry Spot Trade      

When you open a carry spot trade, you are simultaneously buying one currency and selling another. The carry spot hedge cost is based on:

  1. The current exchange rate spread (see the Estimated Spread Cost Breakdown table below)
  2. The interest carry costs (see the Interest Carry Cost Breakdown table below).

The forward rate is priced based on factors such as the following:

  1. the current exchange rate spread, (see the Estimated Spread Cost Breakdown table below)
  2. the interest carry costs (see the Interest Carry Cost Breakdown table below)
  3. a cost to cover potential negative changes to the interest carry costs (see the Interest Risk Cost Breakdown table below)
  4. a flexible built-in commission for the forward contract provider (estimated at $250, although the actual commission may be lower or higher).

Note that this tool provides an estimate only. The forward rates you end up paying will be different from this estimate. Actual forward transaction costs and commissions depend on specific circumstances (length of contract period, customer size, customer knowledge, provider's risk appetite, provider's required profit per transaction, provider's exposure to particular currencies, and so on).

Estimated Spread Cost Breakdown
Amount
()
Spread
()
Hedge Cost
()
Rate
()
Hedge Cost
()
         

The spread is the difference between the bid price (the price you sell at) and the ask price (the price you buy at), quoted in pips. A pip is 1/100 of one percent.

For example, if the quote between EUR/USD at a given moment is 1.5222/1.5223 (sell vs. buy, sometimes expressed as 1.5222/223), then the spread is 1 pip. If the quote is 1.5222/1.5242, then the spread is 20 pips.

The foreign currency rates and spreads are sourced from OANDA’s FXTrade platform. These spreads tend to be standard amounts, except for those times when market liquidity just isn't available (for example, during market events or weekends).

If the forex hedge is between two currencies not traded as a pair on the OANDA FXTrade platform, then the spread is calculated as a synthetic spread, an aggregate of the spreads from two or more currency pairs. For example, if the forex hedge is between the Danish Kroner (DEK) and the Singapore Dollar (SGD), the synthetic spread would include the spreads from both the USD/DEK and USD/SGD pairs.

Interest Carry Cost Breakdown
Interest Type Traded Currency Annual Interest Rate** (%) Amount Traded Annual Interest Traded Currency Exchange Rate* Annual Interest () Interest Over Day Hedge Period ()

The interest carry cost is the difference between the interest paid on the currency sold and the interest earned on the currency purchased during the time the carry spot trade is open.

Each forex hedge has different interest rates associated with it, depending on the currencies involved. You receive interest on the currency you purchase (long), and must pay interest on the currency you sell (short). The difference in these amounts is the carry or interest differential, sometimes referred to as the cost of carry.

All foreign currency transactions that settle in the future (such as futures, forwards and exotics) will have the interest differential cost built into the forward rate. For this example, the interest rate charged/earned is the current interest rate charged by OANDA’s FXTrade. These rates are assumed to be constant throughout the life of the forex hedge (but of course are subject to change at any time).

Each currency has two interest rates at any time: one interest rate paid out when the currency is purchased and a higher rate charged when the currency is sold.

Interest Risk Cost Breakdown
Period (Days) Interest Risk Rate (%) Annual Amount -Day Cost
       

Interest risk premium is a variable amount charged by the issuing party for potential changes in interest rates which would impact the interest carry costs for fixed-priced forex contracts that settle in the future. It is based on the contract’s length and a current assessment of potential interest rate movements in the market. For simplicity, this model uses the following interest risk premium assumptions:

Days OutstandingInterest Risk Premium
0-300.10%
31-600.15%
61-900.25%
91-1200.35%
121-1500.50%
151-1800.75%
181-2701.05%
271-3651.40%
366 or greater1.75%
Interest Safety Margin Breakdown
Savings (Cost)
()
Period Hedge Amount
()
Interest Safety Margin
       
       

When you enter into a carry spot trade for hedging, there is a risk that the interest rates on any of the currencies involved could change unfavorably and increase your cost. This is the most substantial unknown for carry spot hedging and is a risk that is already factored into forward contract pricing.

The interest rate change in this field represents the amount interest rates would need to change unfavorably, immediately and for the entire timeframe, to make the carry spot hedge less attractive than the forward contract estimate. For example, the interest rate on the sold currency would need to increase by the noted amount, or the interest rate on the bought currency would need to fall by this amount, or a combination of these two scenarios.

* Based on current OANDA FXTrade rates. Subject to change.
** Based on current OANDA FXTrade interest rates. Subject to change.

The learning materials on this web site have been developed to enable users to develop an initial level of knowledge of hedge accounting and forex hedging. OANDA does not guarantee the content to be a complete analysis of hedge accounting or forex hedging. The material does not guarantee that users will obtain a complete knowledge of hedge accounting, and will not facilitate making accounting judgments or give users the ability to make hedge accounting decisions.

Examples and other materials on this website are solely for illustrative purposes and should not be relied on for technical answers on technical issues. Before making any hedge accounting decisions, companies should consult their accounting professionals to discuss their specific situations and fact patterns. Neither OANDA nor any of its employees accept any liability whatsoever for any loss or damage, however caused, arising from the use of these tools or documents.